In late 1970, Fotheringay began work on a second album. But after they had laid down basic tracks and guide vocals and were still very much in the middle of the process, Sandy Denny left the band to pursue a solo career, leaving this second record unreleased (though versions of two songs from the sessions, Two Weeks Last Summer and John the Gun, appeared on some Fotheringay/Denny reissues). In the 21st century, guitarist Jerry Donahue, with the help of the two other surviving members (bassist Pat Donaldson and drummer Gerry Conway), worked (according to this CD's liner notes) "on underpinning the original tracks, carefully identifying and assembling the best parts of the 1970 recordings from master tapes which had been dispersed to a variety of locations over the years." This doesn't quite spell out whether some modern overdubbing was undertaken, but however it was accomplished, it's an attempt to reconstruct what might have been Fotheringay's second LP. It's a qualified success in that it does represent a conscientious attempt to finish an unfinished record, even though it can never be finished considering that these cuts have guide vocals (albeit ones that sound pretty good). Even given that limitation, however, it has to be said that this was never going to be a great record even had the time been taken to properly complete it. It's solid early-'70s British folk-rock, but the material's uneven, varying from the excellent (Denny's John the Gun and Late November, as well as their Denny-sung interpretation of the traditional tune Gypsy Davey) to the rather humdrum (a Trevor Lucas-sung cover of Bob Dylan's I Don't Believe You being a low point). And though forgiving fans might be reluctant to point out the elephant in the room, it's plain that Denny's singing and songwriting make the tracks on which those feature leagues above the relatively unexceptional ones written and/or sung by Lucas. Get this by all means to enjoy those pieces featuring Denny's stellar singing, guide vocals or not, with sympathetic accompaniment (if not quite support on the level of Fairport Convention). Don't, however, expect a lost masterpiece. ~ Richie Unterberger, Rovi

1		John the Gun
2		Eppie Moray
3		Wild Mountain Thyme
4		Knights of the Road
5		Late November
6		Restless
7		Gypsy Davey
8		I Don't Believe You
9		Silver Threads and Golden Needles
10		Bold Jack Donahue
11		Two Weeks Last Summer

	Like us on Facebook
	@SoundHound	Follow