Sutton and Sherrill later teamed on a string of hits for Tammy Wynette, among them the chart-topping "I Don't Wanna Play House," "Take Me to Your World," and "Bedtime Story." Wynette even earned her own credit with contributions to two other number ones, "Singing My Song" and "The Ways to Love a Man." Apart from Sherrill, Sutton teamed with producer Jerry Kennedy to write the 1968 Jerry Lee Lewis country chart-topper "To Make Love Sweeter for You." On his own he also penned the Lewis follow-ups "She Still Comes Around (To Love What's Left of Me)" and "What's Made Milwaukee Famous (Has Made a Loser Out of Me)," the latter inspired by a newspaper advertisement and written literally hours before a scheduled studio session. Sutton also spent a number of years as an associate staff producer at Epic Records, where he helmed sessions for Tommy Cash, Jim Jesse, and Bob Luman.
However, it is Sutton's work with Anderson, whom he married in 1968, and the song "Rose Garden," that he may best be remembered for. Written by Joe South and first recorded by Billy Joe Royal in 1967, "(I Never Promised You A) Rose Garden," earned Sutton and Anderson their first number one hit after its release on Columbia in 1970. Sutton later wrote and produced Anderson's other number one hits "You're My Man," "Keep Me in Mind," and "What a Man My Man Is," as well as the Top Ten entries "Sing About Love" and "Stay There 'Til I Get There." Sutton and Anderson divorced in 1977, around the time he revived his long-dormant recording career for Mercury. 1979's "The Football Card" was a minor crossover hit, and he also earned some attention for the novelty record "Red Neck Disco." Inducted into the Nashville Songwriters Hall of Fame in 1999, Sutton died of an apparent heart attack on April 17, 2007. ~ Jason Ankeny, Rovi