It was McCurdy's recordings of more risque folk material, however, that did the most to establish his popularity, especially on college campuses, where the folk audience was branching off into more serious and adult directions. Sin Songs was the first, but the record that sold beyond anyone's expectation was When Dalliance Was in Flower, a 1957 release that, with its songs dwelling on carnal lust, proved a major hit. For a time in the late '50s and early '60s, along with Oscar Brand's various collections of "bawdy songs," When Dalliance Was in Flower was an almost obligatory part of any college-age folk listener's collection, especially if they wanted to impress the opposite sex with something besides singing. A second volume followed in 1958, and a year after that, McCurdy recorded yet another release in this vein, Son of Dalliance. All the while, McCurdy continued to play to younger listeners, and their parents as well, with albums of children's songs.
In 1959, he performed at the Newport Folk Festival, and four of his songs appeared on the third volume of Vanguard Records' Folk Festival at Newport. During the years that followed, McCurdy played the Newport Festival twice more, but after 1960 he was increasingly overshadowed -- as was the case for many singers of his generation -- by the next wave of folk-based topical singer/songwriters, including Bob Dylan. He remained visible as a songwriter, however, as his song Last Night I Had the Strangest Dream, written in 1950, was recorded by the Chad Mitchell Trio in a live version from the Bitter End, and later by artists such as Simon Garfunkel on their first album, Wednesday Morning 3 A.M. (that Simon Garfunkel album was not a success on its initial release, but with their subsequent success, has probably sold over a half-million copies). That song became McCurdy's trademark, and the title track of his final album of new material, released in 1967 when he was 45 years old. That same year, Elektra released The Best of Ed McCurdy. McCurdy lived to be 81, passing away on March 23, 2000 at his home in Halifax, Nova Scotia. ~ Bruce Eder, Rovi