Born on June 8, 1981 in Vista, California, Sara began playing music as a child, learning fiddle as her older brother Sean studied mandolin. Sean met Chris Thile through their mutual tutor and soon the trio formed Nickel Creek in 1989, the year Sara turned eight. Following a debut appearance in Carlsbad, California, the trio became a fixture at bluegrass festivals in the '90s. As they built an audience, they self-released Little Cowpoke in 1993 and Here to There in 1997. They won over Alison Krauss, who helped them get a record deal with Sugar Hill and produced their eponymous debut for the label. Released in 2000, Nickel Creek was an immediate hit in bluegrass and Americana circles, and over the next few years, they steadily built their fan base. This expansion of their audience was helped by sessions and side projects, such as the Mutual Admiration Society, a group featuring all three members of Nickel Creek, Glen Phillips of Toad the Wet Sprocket, and John Paul Jones, the bassist for Led Zeppelin. The Mutual Admiration Society recorded an album which they supported with a tour in 2004.
Nickel Creek's prominence in modern bluegrass and Americana circles helped Watkins land a solo deal with Nonesuch Records in 2008. John Paul Jones produced her self-titled debut, which appeared in April 2009. Although she had gone solo, she hadn't abandoned her Nickel Creek bandmates -- she and her brother Sean often played as the Watkins Family Hour at The Largo in Los Angeles -- nor did she shy away from collaborative work, frequently playing sessions and sharing the stage with all manner of folk, country, and rock musicians.
Sun Midnight Sun, her second solo album, was released in September 2011; it was produced by Blake Mills. Nickel Creek reunited for the 2014 album A Dotted Line, which was followed the next year by an official Watkins Family Hour album. Watkins moved to New West Records for 2016's Young in All the Wrong Ways.
In 2017, Watkins united with fellow singer/songwriters Aoife O'Donovan and Sarah Jarosz to form I'm with Her, who released their debut album, See You Around, in February 2018. Watkins Family Hour released Brother Sister in 2020, then the fiddler returned to her solo career in 2021 with Under the Pepper Tree, a children's album inspired by her newborn baby. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine, Rovi