While at the Grange, the band recorded second album Strange Affair, released in early 1972, with the addition of Graham and Jonathan JoJo Glemser to the band. Graham and Glemser left during the recording of Strange Affair and were replaced by Paul Burton for the completion of the album. The lineup of Burton, Morley, Treece, and Charles recorded another album almost immediately, Beware the Shadow, which was released at the end of 1972. None of the first three albums were big sellers. The Helps, as they were called by fans, appealed to a hippie audience and found moderate success in the U.S., where they appealed to Deadheads and fans of such bands as Quicksilver. Glam rock was the big rage in England at the time, but Help Yourself were found to be a bit too rural for radio play, especially in England, so there was basically no promotion or support for the band.
In 1973, Ken Whaley returned to the band and the Helps recorded an album that was appropriately called The Return of Ken Whaley. The initial release of that album contained a "bonus" album called Happy Days, which was recorded live on tour with the Flying Aces. Shortly after the release of The Return of Ken Whaley, Help Yourself broke up. Malcolm Morley went on to join the Welsh band Man, with Ken Whaley later joining him there. The remaining bandmembers joined Deke Leonard's Iceberg and recorded a couple of albums, while Treece later joined George and Martin Ace in the Flying Aces. The original lineup of Help Yourself re-formed in 2002 to help remix tracks originally intended for their long lost fifth album. Compiling material recorded in 1973 alongside three new recordings (featuring drummer Kevin Spacey), 5 was released by Hux Records in 2004. ~ Keith Pettipas, Rovi